Dark Night of the Soul: The Ultimate Identity Crisis

Hello Soul Family,

While I was reworking my inner child and shadow work book, I noticed I hadn’t really given dark nights of the soul the time and space they deserve. To explain one properly, I had to unpack psychological theory that is VERY important if you want to understand why we go through this dark night at all. After a bit of research, I wasn’t satisfied with what I found, because no one had named what a dark night of the soul truly is—it is an identity crisis. This is a crisis left unresolved from our teen years, and because we resolve it so much later than we first faced it, navigating it can feel like a rollercoaster. Yes, it can absolutely feel like a dark night.

Why does Erik Erikson matter here? He was the FIRST to recognize identity as a major personality achievement that unfolds during adolescence. He described these teen-year feelings as the “identity vs. role confusion” stage. Every account of dark nights I read mentioned feeling depressed, yet this is not simply depression or intense sadness. What happens in a dark night of the soul is that your cognitive dissonance shatters—your sense of reality. Everything you knew to be true comes crashing down. Your whole world feels like a lie, fake, false. This is a very delicate stage, because people also tend to dissociate at this time. It is also VERY normal to feel these emotions.

If you’ve been dissociating, please read my dissociation blog!

What is self-actualization? Psychologists call it the highest level of psychological development—the point where personal potential is fully realized once basic bodily and ego needs are met. Sound familiar? How is that different from becoming one with your highest, most authentic self? For as long as society has existed, people have struggled with self-actualization. That’s because people in this world are egotistical and deeply rooted in wanting to control everything around them. Is EVERYONE like that? No. But most of us are ego driven until we do our shadow work and inner child healing—that’s for sure. This becomes a problem because when we don’t mind our business, we people please, we don’t know how to rest or receive, we don’t ask for help, we constantly try to save everyone else, and we pour ourselves out until we’re empty—leaving nothing for ourselves. Knowing the aspects that shape our personality matters, and it’s a big part of why I do the work I do.

These 8 stages are rarely discussed outside a psychology class, yet they are SUCH an important part of what shapes our personality and, yes, our sense of identity. Look over and down this list and you’ll see we get a chance to self-actualize at various stages of life. It’s meant to move us toward joy, happiness, and fulfillment, yet those who never take that path tend to feel stagnation and then despair. A person who leans toward stagnation and despair is someone who did not self-actualize—someone who never found themselves or a sense of identity that felt fulfilling.

We also have other stages that help with this identity crisis if we fail to explore properly and find ourselves as a teen. There’s the quarterlife crisis around age 25, and then the Saturn Return between 27 and 30. These two young-adulthood stages are meant to cultivate our sense of identity for those of us who missed the boat earlier. Yet many of us are emotionally avoidant, so many people suppress and repress the triggers and emotions that surface at this time. Many feel inadequate during this period because they feel that pull toward purpose. They feel they aren’t living in their joy or happiness yet. They feel like, what the fuck am I doing with my life? What have I done with my life?

We keep asking ourselves those questions at various ages until the issue of identity is resolved. People who wake up at 45 and don’t know who the fuck they are—we say they’re having a midlife crisis. Yet again, what people FAIL to see is what all these crises share: identity. Those of us who fail to self-actualize and find a purposeful identity will likely feel stagnant and then despair as we grow into old age. THIS is a big part of why I teach this, so none of you have to enter those stages of life in stagnation or despair. I want everyone to understand how this works, because the more you know, the easier it becomes to break down the wounds. My wish for all of you is self-actualization, because there is no greater place in this world than being exactly where you were meant to be all along. Look over this list of Erikson’s 8 stages so you can understand how personality forms from birth on.

What are Erikson’s 8 psychosocial stages?

  • Basic Trust vs. Mistrust: (birth-1 year) When an infant receives warm and responsive care, they will develop a sense of trust or confidence that the world is good. Yet a sense of mistrust will develop when an infant has to wait too long for care, or if they are handled harshly. This can be positively resolved through quality caregiving and promptly relieving the infants discomfort. Also, through sensitively holding the infant through feedings, patiently waiting until they have had enough milk, and then weaning when the infant shows less interest in the breast or bottle. When the balance of care is sympathetic and loving, the psychological conflict of the first year can be resolved on the positive side. A trusting infant will expect the world to be good and gratifying, which will make them feel confident about exploring and venturing out. A mistrustful infant will have learned that they cannot count on others kindness or compassion, they cannot trust others. The mistrustful baby will withdraw from people and things around them.
  • Autonomy vs. Shame and Doubt: (1-3 years) Children at this stage want to explore with their new mental and motor skills. They want to choose and decide for themselves. Autonomy is developed when parents permit the child reasonable free choice and do not shame or force the child. At this age toddlers have a sense of budding selfhood, and they want to decide for themselves. This stage is resolved positively when parents provide their children with suitable guidance and reasonable choices. A self-confident toddler is one who has been encouraged to potty train, eat with a spoon, and pick up their toys. Their parents do not criticize them or attack them when they make mistakes or fail at properly performing new skills. Their parents also allow the child to assert themselves with tolerance and understanding. Parents who are over or under controlling tend to leave their children feeling forced or shamed, which can lead a child to doubt their ability to control their impulses or act competently on their own. Basic trust and autonomy grow from warm and sensitive parenting and reasonable expectations for impulse control. If a child emerges from its first few years without developing trust in their caregivers and without a healthy sense of individuality, the seeds will be sown for adjustment problems. This can lead to someone who in adulthood will have difficulty establishing intimate bonds, can become overly dependent on loved ones, or who continues to doubt their own ability to meet new challenges.
  • Initiative vs. Guilt: (3-6 years) Once a child builds a sense of autonomy they will become less difficult. Their energies are freed to tackle this next stage of initiative, where the child finds a sense of purposefulness. They are eager to learn new tasks, join in activities with peers, and discover what they can do. They now make strides in conscience and moralistic development. Children at this stage explore the kind of person they could become through make believe play which allows them to try new skills with little risk of failure or criticism. Parents can help a child develop initiative, which is a sense of responsibility and ambition, by supporting their child’s new sense of purpose. Parents who demand too much self-control at this stage, can lead a child to feel guilt due to their over control. This guilt develops due to the child feeling as though they do not meet their parents expectations. The best way to foster initiative is by allowing the child to lead where they would like to go and support as best as you can. The negative outcome of this will become an overly strict superego, one that will cause the child to feel too much guilt due to being threatened, criticized, or excessively punished by adults. When this happens, their ability to participate in exuberant play and their bold efforts to master new tasks breaks down.
  • Industry vs. Inferiority: (6-11 years) Children who’s experiences have been positive enter this stage of middle childhood, prepared to redirect their energy from make believe play into real accomplishments. At this age a combination of adult expectations and the child’s own ambitions for mastery will drive the conflict of industry. This conflict is positively resolved when the child develops a sense of competence and useful skills and tasks. Children at this stage are often in school, which helps the child develop the capacity to work and cooperate with others. Inferiority develops when a child experiences negative events at home, at school, or with peers. This can develop into feelings of incompetence, which can be dangerous. Children can develop pessimism and have little confidence in their ability to do anything well. This sense of inadequacy can develop either when a family life has not prepared the child for school life or when the child has negative experiences with teachers or peers that destroy their feelings of competence or mastery. When industry is developed this leads to a positive but realistic concept of self, pride in accomplishment, moral responsibility, and cooperative participation with peers.
  • Identity vs. Role Confusion: (adolescence) At this stage, the adolescent will try to answer the questions: Who am I? What is my purpose? What is my place in society? Identity is a MAJOR personality achievement and will be a crucial step towards becoming a happy and productive adult. Constructing an identity involves defining who you are, what you value, and the directions you choose to explore in life. By exploring values and vocational goals, the young person can form a personal identity. The search for what is real and truth about the self will begin to drive many choices- morals, religious values, political ideals, interpersonal relationships, vocational, community involvement, and expression of sexual orientation. Successful outcomes of earlier stages will ensure a smooth transition into identity. If the child has a weak sense of trust, have trouble finding things to believe in. Those with little autonomy or initiative tend to not engage in active exploration. Those who lack a sense of industry fail to choose vocations that reflects their interests and skills. At this age children will experience an identity crisis which is defined as a temporary period of confusion and distress as they experiment with alternatives before settling on goals and values. Those who go through this process will end up with a mature identity. If they are not allowed to form a personal identity due to pressure from parents or society, this will lead to confusion about future adult roles. If the earlier conflicts were unresolved negatively or if society limits their choices, they may be unprepared for adulthood and find it difficult in the next stage to establish deeper bonds of intimacy.
  • Intimacy vs. Isolation: (emerging adulthood) As the journey through identity continues, a young person will continue to work on establishing intimate ties with other people. The major task of these years will revolve around establishing deep and intimate bonds with others. The increasing closeness of relationships will extend well into the next stage of adulthood. Relationships with other will now become deeper and last longer, and involve greater levels of trust, emotional closeness, support, and commitment. Their concept of relationships will grow and become more complex. These relationships will express a larger range of desired qualities and responses from others and the self. Some individuals will not be able to form these deep and intimate bonds though, this is typically due to earlier disappointments. This will often lead them to remain in a state of isolation.
  • Generativity vs. Stagnation: (adulthood) At this part of the journey, we are giving back to the world and the next generation. This can be through a various means of ways such as child rearing, caring for other people, or through productive work. If we fail to meet this generativity, we feel an absence of meaning or a sense of accomplishment.
  • Integrity vs. Despair: (old age) At this final stage, individuals will reflect on the kind of person they have been and the life they have led. Integrity will develop if the person feels as though they have led a life that was worth living. Despair will develop if they are dissatisfied with their lives, which will often cause them to also fear dying

Well Soul Fam, I hope this information helped you connect some dots. Until next time… Sending mucho luz + amor always!


XoXo,
Luna Estrellas

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Understanding the dark night of the soul as an identity crisis reframes it from something to fear into a stage of growth. Erikson’s eight psychosocial stages show how trust, autonomy, initiative, industry, identity, intimacy, generativity, and integrity build on one another across a lifetime. When an earlier stage is left unresolved, the questions resurface later—often as a quarterlife crisis, a Saturn Return, or a midlife crisis—until the work of self-actualization is done.