Colorism and the Clark Doll Experiments

Hello Soul Fam!

During this week's Thankful Thursday, we explored colorism through the Clark Doll experiments and the documentaries Dark Girls, Dark Girls 2, and Light Girls. If the concept is new to you, colorism refers to prejudice or discrimination against people with darker skin, usually within the same ethnic or racial group. Before diving in, I want to clarify a few terms. Defining them helps highlight their clear differences, since many people use them interchangeably and some may be unfamiliar. Prejudice is a preconceived opinion not grounded in reason or actual experience. Discrimination is the unjust or prejudicial treatment of different categories of people or things, especially based on race, age, or sex. Stereotyping, in social psychology, is an over-generalized belief about a particular group—an expectation applied to every person in that group. Microaggression describes brief, everyday verbal, behavioral, or environmental slights—intentional or not—that convey hostile, derogatory, or negative attitudes toward stigmatized or marginalized groups. Finally, racism is prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed at people because of their racial or ethnic group, typically one that is a minority or marginalized. Racism also refers to the belief that races possess distinct characteristics, abilities, or qualities used to rank them as inferior or superior.

With that covered, let's turn to the Clark Doll experiments and why they were so vital to America's education system and school desegregation. In the late 1930s, Kenneth Clark and his wife, Mamie Phipps Clark, set out to study how segregation affected African-American schoolchildren psychologically, especially their self-image. This couple was a true powerhouse of their era! Their joint research reshaped the education system forever. They were also the first African-American man and woman to earn PhDs in Psychology from Columbia University. They dared to ask whether prejudice toward different groups is inborn or learned. Since it's Black History Month, I strongly encourage you to learn about this couple and their essential work. I'll include some articles at the end of this section so you can research them further.

There is much evidence that suggest that racial attitudes are not inborn, nor is it the case that race doesn’t influence a child’s perception of themselves or the world until later years. The Clarks research suggested that racial attitudes gradually develop over the first few years of life. This research has been replicated many times over, and it has always been consistent with showing that children as young as three show an awareness for racial cues, and even show a preference for one race over the others. As children get older, their attitudes about racial groups become more coherent, complex, and intense. The Clarks research showed that there was little difference in the racial attitudes of 6th graders versus high school students.

The Clarks are best known for creating the Doll experiments. They used this experiment to measure children's awareness of racial differences and their underlying attitudes about race. The experiment used four dolls and tested children ages three to seven. The dolls were identical except for skin color, which ranged from white to dark brown. They found that the children could demonstrate racial awareness by correctly identifying the dolls based on their own skin tone. They could also identify themselves racially by choosing the doll that looked most like them. To explore how the children felt about race, they were asked another series of questions—such as pointing out the doll they liked best or wanted to play with, the doll with a nice color, which doll was the nice doll, and which doll looked bad. They found that black children clearly preferred the white dolls while rejecting the black dolls. In psychological terms, this was interpreted as indirect self-rejection. They concluded that this reflected the children's tendency to absorb racial prejudices present in society and turn them inward, internalizing them.

The Clarks determined that as children learn to evaluate racial differences according to social standards, they must identify with a specific group, each carrying an implied status within a hierarchy. The young black children who preferred the white doll showed they were well aware of society's preference for white people. Children as young as three expressed attitudes similar to the adults in their communities. The Clarks concluded that these attitudes formed from a mix of influences, including parents, teachers, friends, television, movies, and books. They noted that while most parents don't deliberately teach their children to hate other groups, they may subtly and unconsciously pass on dominant social attitudes.

The Clarks insisted that segregation was damaging the personalities of both white and black children alike. Kenneth Clark’s expert testimony in Brown vs. Board of Education of Topeka was instrumental in determining that racial segregation was unconstitutional in public schools. This contributed directly to the desegregation of the public school system.

Here are some articles that discuss the significance of this experiment and its instrumental role in the education system.

www.naacpldf.org/ldf-celebrates-60th-anniversary-brown-v-board-education/significance-doll-test/

www.history.com/news/brown-v-board-of-education-doll-experiment

Here are a couple of videos demonstrating the Clark Doll experiment:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=DYCz1ppTjiM

www.youtube.com/watch?v=QRZPw-9sJtQ

According to psychologists, parents are the first and most powerful source of information about the world, and children are strongly influenced by it. Other research suggests that children develop stereotypes and prejudices either through direct teaching by parents or family, or from a family environment that promotes negative outgroup attitudes (Allport, 1954). Yet in the early years (before age 10), children don't grasp the meaning or impact of stereotypes, so they can't truly internalize these attitudes until they're older. In early life, children are simply mimicking their parents' outgroup sentiments (Rohan & Zanna, 1996). This is interesting because it means children under 10 base their racial attitudes solely on their parents and/or environment. Once a child reaches an age (usually 11–13) with a higher cognitive level, they understand the impact and implications of racial attitudes and may choose to change them or keep what they've learned—though psychologists believe this also depends on parenting style. Children are more likely to adopt their parents' attitudes and values unless they perceive their parent as both demanding and unresponsive. Children shown a lack of attention and consideration were less willing to adopt similar attitudes and values.

Psychological research suggests that white families in particular often never discuss race with their children. This can be extremely damaging to a child's perception of other cultures. Race is something that MUST be discussed, and in our current times, this is no time to sweep these issues under the rug. For families who struggle to talk with their children about race, please check out these articles:

www.psychology.uga.edu/children-teenagers-and-racism

www.psychology.uga.edu/discussing-race-white-families

Let's look at why racial issues may not be openly discussed among racial groups (especially white people), according to the American Psychological Association:

  • Defensiveness about issues of privilege. Value judgments (e.g., good vs. bad) may inaccurately be attributed to privilege. Naming privilege is not about placing blame; rather, it is about helping those who are in positions of privilege recognize and acknowledge the presence of privilege and the benefits experienced as a result.
  • Fear of appearing “-ist” (racist). People may experience intense anxiety because they fear their statements may be interpreted as representing racially biased attitudes, values, or beliefs and may hesitate or be disinclined to participate as a result.
  • Fear of realizing one’s own “-ist”. People may experience fear if they realize they do indeed hold beliefs or values that are racist in nature.
  • Fear of confronting one’s privilege. Once individuals recognize that they benefit from privilege, they may recognize ways in which they have abused privilege or, alter-natively, erroneously attributed the negative results of a disadvantaged status to personal inadequacies or failures.
  • Fear of responsibility for taking steps to end oppression. Recognition that taking action, or failing to take action, to end the oppression of others is a decision.
  • Monologuing. People may become entrenched in explaining/defending their position rather than listening with the intention of hearing, under-standing, and exchanging information and ideas.
  • Emotional content. Intense, debilitating emotion often arises that can interfere with a person’s ability to be vulnerable, present, honest, and open.
  • Power differentials between whites and people of color. There is an inherent power differential between people of color and whites in America. Because of this imbalance of power, people of color are more susceptible to negative outcomes following candid conversations about race. These include harassment, job loss, physical violence, or worse. It follows that people of color, who are already grappling with the burden of racism and social oppression, may be reluctant to engage in discussions that could garner additional hostility.

That said, please understand that in today's racial climate, now is not the time to sweep things under the rug and act as if they don't exist. Now is not the time to walk around in the delusion that you are color blind. Now is the time to address the many issues in our society that have existed for many, many years because no one has had the courage to do anything about them.

This list was taken from here, and the full text can be read here:

www.apa.org/education/undergrad/diversity/facing-divide-instructor-guide.pdf

Colorism is a by-product of racism that has spread across the entire world. Visit any continent and you'll encounter colorism—a caste system in which people with darker skin are treated unequally and unfairly. THAT is how insidious and pervasive racism has been in this world. You literally cannot go anywhere without this system being instituted, which is rather depressing when you consider its implications. There are women in Africa right now bleaching their beautiful skin to achieve a lighter appearance. In Asia, women fear walking in the sun and are often seen with an open umbrella on a sunny day. In India, there are even vaginal bleaching creams, because apparently if your vulva isn't light, it isn't right. Don't believe me? Check out their commercial here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=9wy3rcJ8sco and here's an article discussing it:

www.huffpost.com/entry/vagina-brightening-indian-tv-ad_n_1577555

I want to stress this point about colorism because people rarely discuss it or its deep effects on our society at large. Colorism has been the biggest way to KEEP US DIVIDED. It is a product of the Willie Lynch system institutionalized hundreds of years ago, first in the Caribbean and South America, then in America. If you've never read it, I highly recommend searching for The Willie Lynch Letter: The Making of a Slave, which is widely available. It will give you insight into the psychological warfare inflicted on black women in those times. This is the structure we still live in today. The psychological trauma inflicted on enslaved women especially was done with absolute reason, as women tend to be their children's first teachers and tend to impart their values and attitudes about the world. By psychologically traumatizing the women, they ensured that their trauma and fear was passed on to the next generation, and the next, and so on.

The following documentaries were made to address colorism and raise awareness about the topic and the experiences of both dark-skinned and light-skinned black women as they navigate the world. While I didn't find all of these documentaries free in their entirety on YouTube, I did find them across several platforms. That said, check your Netflix, Amazon, and Hulu to see if any are currently available in full. YouTube also has a rental option. Information on Dark Girls 2 can be found on the OWN website, and I'll provide all the links below.

For Dark Girls info and trailer:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=J7GeGRulqYE&list=PL_9XsRagnPlO_U_yoaTR1z5708cmJxUX7&index=3

For Dark Girls 2 info, check out the OWN site at:

www.oprah.com/app/dark-girls-2.html

For Light Girls info and trailer:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=kN_81iytSXU&list=PL5Lmju0XfLrnItu5JgooJ_dJgKmomLYmC

Please take the time to watch these documentaries and make it a family affair. Let this be a way for you to openly speak with your families about these issues and the division they cause within the collective at large. Take this time to educate yourselves on these issues. Nothing can improve until we all start caring a little bit more.

I hope this information helps you, Soul Fam. Until next week, sending mucho luz + amor always.

XoXo,

Luna Estrellas

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Understanding the Clark Doll experiments helps connect the history of segregation to the everyday ways colorism still shapes how people see themselves and others. The documentaries and articles shared here are meant as starting points for family conversations about race, privilege, and the attitudes children absorb from the world around them.