Attachment Styles

Hey Soul Fam!

This week on Thankful Thursday we explored attachment styles. Why does this matter so much? Because your attachment style is how you build your sense of self, and that sense of self carries into adulthood, shaping how you bond and love in both platonic and romantic relationships. Attachment styles usually lock in during our first year, though for some they don't settle until the third year in cases of neglect or abandonment. Either way, within our first five years we form our sense of self, determined solely by the connection we have with our parents—primarily our mother. While early studies centered on the mother's role in this dynamic, newer research has brought the father's role to the forefront as well.

To dig into the psychology behind attachment styles, take a look at this article:

www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/communication-success/201507/what-is-your-relationship-attachment-style

It's a great article, but it gets the credit wrong: the first psychologists to coin Attachment Theory were Bowlby and Ainsworth. They discovered these attachment styles in children, and many later experiments were built on their original model, especially once researchers began testing adults. Everything we know about adult attachment styles traces back to Bowlby and Ainsworth's original experiments.

Bowlby believed that newborn infants, completely helpless, were genetically predisposed to form an attachment with their mothers in order to survive. Any condition that threatened to separate mother and child would trigger instinctive attachment behaviors along with feelings of insecurity and fear. These ideas became his theory, which sought to explain the lifelong importance of the mother-infant bond and the psychological difficulties a child would face if that bond were damaged or completely broken.

He believed the bond was so deeply formative that if it fails to form or breaks down within the first few years of life, the child will suffer negative consequences later on. He also argued there was a critical period during which this attachment should form—during the first year of life, but at the very latest before the child's second birthday. Bowlby thought any attempts at mothering beyond age three would be useless, since the child would already be on course to suffer the effects of maternal deprivation. The studies on Maternal Deprivation were especially interesting: children who had not formed a more secure attachment to a maternal figure seemed rougher in play, showed less initiative, more overexcitement, and were less competitive than peers with more traditional upbringings. In some extreme cases, maternal deprivation was also found to lead to “affectionless psychopathy,” a clinical condition in which people are unable to care deeply for others and so don't form meaningful interpersonal relationships. Those who suffer from it show a higher incidence of juvenile delinquency and antisocial behavior without any sign of remorse. These people are unable to experience guilt. In a study of juvenile thieves, many had been separated from their mothers for six or more months before they were five years old.

According to Bowlby, this primary secure attachment matters so much because it is essential to developing an inner working model—the framework a child then uses to understand themselves, others, and the world. This model guides a person's thoughts, feelings, and expectations in all their personal relationships. Since this primary attachment style serves as the prototype for all future relationships, its quality determines whether a child grows to trust others, see themselves as valuable, and feel confident in society. Like many aspects of personality and character formed in childhood, this working model is also resistant to change once formed. It tends to determine how a person behaves and even the kind of bond they will form with their own children—usually a reflection of their own attachment style. This is probably the most important reason to correct an insecure attachment style: otherwise you are doomed to raise your children the same way and continue the cycle unless you change. It starts with YOU.

Later studies, however, incorporated other attachment figures, and children were found to attach to their fathers as well as to other adults. Bowlby believed the father had no direct emotional significance for the infant, contributing only indirectly by supporting the mother emotionally and financially. Yet other psychologists have challenged these theories by looking at multiple cultures where fathers were far more involved in childcare. Growing numbers of fathers are taking on the role of principal parent, which suggests parenting roles are a consequence of social convention and NOT biology. Women are NOT genetically or biologically predisposed to be better parents.

Bowlby's views implied that men will inevitably be the inferior parent, but other studies—mainly from Schaffer and Parke—suggest men are equally capable of providing warmth and sensitivity to their infants. They also found that a child's developmental outcome is determined not by a parent's gender but by the strength and quality of the bond formed. Other studies found that infants and children display a wide range of attachment behaviors toward many people besides their mothers, and that multiple attachments are more common than previously believed. This echoes the old saying that “it takes a village to raise a child.” In many cultures this proved true, and child rearing was more a community activity than a task or duty resting squarely on one person's shoulders.

Despite many criticisms and revisions to Bowlby's work, it remains the most influential and comprehensive account of attachment styles to date. Psychologists have used this basic premise to delve deeper into childhood attachment patterns and to develop theories of adult attachment, exploring how the parent-child bond can influence the future bond between spouses and romantic partners. His theories have also helped in aspects of child rearing and led to many more studies exploring this.

One of those studies in particular was conducted by Harry Harlow, using baby monkeys to show the importance of contact comfort. Many psychologists before him believed attachment formed with a caregiver simply because that person fed them, and that an infant often preferred whoever fed them and met their basic need for food. Harlow was determined to prove them all wrong. So he took these monkeys from their mothers and placed them in cages with “surrogate” mothers. There were two surrogate mothers in this experiment—one made of wire but rigged with a feeding bottle, the other with no bottle but made of terry cloth. The infants spent most of their time with the terry cloth mother, even though it could not feed them, and used it as a secure base, often clinging to it for comfort when frightening objects were placed in the cage. In later tests, the cloth mother could rock and provide food, and their attachment grew even stronger. Harlow went on to suggest that breastfeeding's main function might be to ensure close body contact with the mother. THIS study was groundbreaking in so many ways and is why breastfeeding and body contact with an infant are viewed as important today. It changed how parenting was approached in the Western world. To learn more about this experiment, check out this article:

www.psychologicalscience.org/publications/observer/obsonline/harlows-classic-studies-revealed-the-importance-of-maternal-contact.html

Now let's move on to the attachment styles themselves and learn what they are. What are the attachment styles?

Secure Attachment – Securely attached adults tend to be more satisfied in their relationships. Children with a secure attachment see their parent as a secure base from which they can venture out and explore the world independently. A secure adult has a similar relationship with their romantic partner, feeling secure and connected while allowing themselves and their partner to move freely. Secure adults offer support when their partner feels distressed, and they go to their partner for comfort when they themselves feel troubled. Their relationship tends to be honest, open, and equal, with both people feeling independent yet loving toward each other. Securely attached couples don't tend to engage in what my father calls Fantasy Bonds—an illusion of connection that provides a false sense of safety. In a fantasy bond, a couple forgoes real acts of love for a more routine, emotionally cut-off form of relating.

Anxious Preoccupied Attachment – Unlike securely attached couples, people with an anxious attachment tend to be desperate to form a fantasy bond. Instead of feeling real love or trust toward their partner, they often feel emotional hunger. They frequently look to their partner to rescue or complete them. Although they seek safety and security by clinging to their partner, they take actions that push their partner away. Even though anxiously attached individuals act desperate or insecure, more often than not their behavior worsens their own fears. When they feel unsure of their partner's feelings and unsafe in their relationship, they often become clingy, demanding, or possessive toward their partner. They may also read independent actions by their partner as confirmation of their fears. For example, if their partner starts socializing more with friends, they may think, “See? He doesn't really love me. This means he is going to leave me. I was right not to trust him.”

Dismissive Avoidant Attachment – People with a dismissive avoidant attachment tend to emotionally distance themselves from their partner. They may seek isolation and feel “pseudo-independent,” taking on the role of parenting themselves. They often come off as self-focused and may be overly attentive to their creature comforts. Pseudo-independence is an illusion, since every human being needs connection. Nevertheless, people with a dismissive avoidant attachment tend to lead more inward lives, denying the importance of loved ones and detaching easily from them. They are often psychologically defended and able to shut down emotionally. Even in heated or emotional situations, they can turn off their feelings and not react. For example, if their partner is distressed and threatens to leave them, they would respond by saying, “I don't care.”

Fearful Avoidant Attachment – A person with a fearful avoidant attachment lives in an ambivalent state of being afraid of being both too close to or too distant from others. They attempt to keep their feelings at bay but are unable to; they can’t just avoid their anxiety or run away from their feelings. Instead, they are overwhelmed by their reactions and often experience emotional storms. They tend to be mixed up or unpredictable in their moods. They see their relationships from the working model that you need to go towards others to get your needs met, but if you get close to others, they will hurt you. In other words, the person they want to go to for safety is the same person they are frightened to be close to. As a result, they have no organized strategy for getting their needs met by others. As adults, these individuals tend to find themselves in rocky or dramatic relationships, with many highs and lows. They often have fears of being abandoned but also struggle with being intimate. They may cling to their partner when they feel rejected, then feel trapped when they are close. Oftentimes, the timing seems to be off between them and their partner. A person with fearful avoidant attachment may even wind up in an abusive relationship.

Uncovering your attachment style matters when you do inner child healing, because it determines how you view yourself and others. It determines how you value yourself, whether you can trust yourself and others, how you form bonds, and how you love. The upside is that it's never too late to develop a secure attachment. The attachment style you developed as a child, based on your relationship with a parent or early caretaker, does NOT have to define how you relate to those you love in your adult life. Once you know your attachment style, you can uncover the ways you defend yourself from getting close and being emotionally connected, and work toward forming an “earned secure attachment.” To find out what your attachment style is, check out this site. It has a quiz you can take, and the entire site is dedicated to attachment styles and educating the masses about them:

www.attachmentproject.com/attachment-style-quiz/

You can also check out this article from the site, which includes videos explaining attachment styles:

www.attachmentproject.com/blog/four-attachment-styles/

I hope these tips help you out, Soul Fam—until next week! Sending mucho luz + amor always.

XoXo,

Luna Estrellas

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Knowing your attachment style is a starting point, not a label. As you read through the secure, anxious, dismissive avoidant, and fearful avoidant patterns, notice which descriptions feel familiar without judging yourself for them. That awareness is what makes an earned secure attachment possible—one built on understanding how you connect, trust, and love.